NYC: Not Far From The Madding Crowd

2008 April 23

Never fish Central Park during a school holiday. I headed up to the Park and met up with Randy Kadish and Matt Stansberry’s brother Nate to try for some bass. So did about 800 other people. I guess when you’re in a city comprised of millions, expecting to find fly fishing solace on a 70 degree day in the Park when school’s out is not realistic.  For every ten feet of water I worked, a guy with a spinner and a soft plastic rig would be working ahead of me. Sloppy seconds doesn’t get the bass. Kids were throwing rocks in the remaining heretofore undisturbed water. We were lucky to get a couple of bluegill and crappie.

Still, there’s something gratifying about clicking through the subway turnstile with a rod tube in hand, knowing that in five stops you’ll be casting to fish. I’m debating making it a lunch break deal. And here’s the thing that’s going to keep me going back. Giant freaking carp finning in the shallows like bonefish; 20-plus pounders rooting around with their tails out. Of course, they wanted nothing to do with anything I threw. Why hit flies when the guys down the way are using balled up bits of tortilla shell? (They ignored that, too.) It’s enough to make you insane. This is a game I’m determined to learn.

13 Responses leave one →
  1. 2008 April 23
    Natalie permalink

    Yes, fishing in Central Park on a school day — and in between tourist group visits to the lake — is optimum. I haven’t wet a line there yet this Spring as The Lake is under ‘renovation.’ Thank you for your posts. Fish on!

  2. 2008 April 24

    Fly fishing in the Central park??? WOW!!! That´s rare…

  3. 2008 April 24

    When I got there it was great to see so many girls fishing.

    Yes, Central Park is tough, tough fishing: wild bass with a lot of bait fish for them to eat.

    Right now the bass are spawning.

    The Meer is a great place to practice my roll casting. Have to get a switch or spey rod soon.

    Randy

  4. 2008 April 24
    mstansberry permalink

    This might sound insane, but how about getting there pre-work instead of at lunch? You’ll beat the crowds.

  5. 2008 April 24

    Good idea, although it’s getting to the time of year that if I’m going to get up and go fishing before work, it’s going to be for stripers.

  6. 2008 April 24
    mstansberry permalink

    Right. I figured it’d be tough to justify getting up that early w/ out hitting the salt.

  7. 2008 April 25
    Nate Stansberry permalink

    It’s on! I’m telling you… and after this weekend I’ll have pics to back it up!

  8. 2008 April 26

    Central Park or not . Aren’t bass out of season in NYS?

  9. 2008 April 27

    Crowldawg, it’s a catch and release only for bass, using only artificials, until the third Saturday in June. Since the Park is always catch-and-release, you can pretty much fish for largemouth there year round.

  10. 2008 April 27

    Pete,
    not to be a pain in the ass
    “Taking and Possession of Fish
    A person may not fish for a species (not even catch and release) during the closed season for that species on a given water.” This is right off their web page
    Ive had my butt chewed out more than a few times when I criticized people for catching striped bass out of season.
    tom

  11. 2008 April 27

    Excuse me,”Their ,” being the New York DEC

  12. 2008 April 27

    I hear you Crowldawg, but catch and release only is allowed for them from Dec. 1st through the third Saturday in June, with limited take after that. See under “black bass” here:

    http://www.dec.ny.gov/regs/4026.html

    Then if you scroll down and look at the regs by county it says for New York and Central Park all catch and release all year.

    I think you’re thinking of striped bass in saltwater, which is April 15 – Dec 15:

    http://www.dec.ny.gov/outdoor/7894.html

    Totally different regs than for freshwater bass.

  13. 2008 April 27

    Actually Crowldawg, I see where you’re getting your info. For Nassau and Suffolk Counties, the rules are different. All fishing for bass is prohibited between March 15 and the third Saturday in June.

Leave a Reply

Note: You can use basic XHTML in your comments. Your email address will never be published.

Subscribe to this comment feed via RSS