The genteel trout anglers take aim at one another in this PDF of a New York Times book review from 1914:
An Expert’s Reply to a Criticism of the Dry-Fly Method With Some Pertinent Comments
-
Recent Comments
WindKnot on Things That Matter on the… Pete McDonald on The Drinking Man’s Guide… MG on The Drinking Man’s Guide… Pete McDonald on Things That Matter on the… WindKnot on Things That Matter on the… Copyright Notice
© Pete McDonald and Fishing Jones (www.fishingjones.com), 2003-2012. Unauthorized use and/or duplication of this material without express and written permission from this blog’s author is strictly prohibited. Excerpts and links may be used, provided that full and clear credit is given to Fishing Jones with appropriate and specific direction to the original content. (This means you, scraper.)-
My Flickr Photos
More Photos Fly Fishing Blogs
- 111 Degrees West
- A Bad Backcast
- AJ Sutts Blog
- Alex Kain 40 Rivers
- Angler Wannabe
- Arizona Wanderings
- Bonefish on the Brain
- Bows and Browns
- Buster Wants To Fish
- Carolina Redfish
- Carp on the Fly
- Catching My Fair Share
- Chi Wulff
- Creek Addict
- Deneki
- Eat The Fly
- Fat Guy Fly Fishing
- Fiberglass Manifesto
- Fish Eat Flies
- FishBeer
- Fisherman's Trail
- Fishing & Thinking
- Fishing Poet
- Flats Walker
- Flies and Fins
- Fly and Gin
- Fly Art By Gary
- Fly Carpin
- Fly Fish Addiction
- Fly Fish Chick
- Fly Fish Long Island
- Fly Fish Yellowstone
- Fly Fisher Girl
- Fly River
- Fly Talk
- Fly Tyer
- FlyFish Journal
- FlyFishMagazine
- Focal Fish
- Foul Hooked
- Gink and Gasoline
- Glassy Waters
- Headhunter's Fly Shop Blog
- Headwaters of History
- iRiver Rat
- Lateral Line Media
- Lowbrow Angler
- Man in the Striped Pajamas
- McFluffchucker
- Megalops Atlanticus
- Michael Gracie
- Midcurrent
- Mike's Gone Fishing
- Moldy Chum
- Mysteries Internal
- Mystic Fishing
- New Brunswick Fly Fishing
- Old Smuggler Fly Fishing
- Ozark Fly Angler's Journal
- Patagonia Flies
- Pike Fly Fishing
- Prairie Ocean Fly Fisher
- Primal Fly
- Rise Fishing Blog
- Rogue Angels
- Roughfisher
- Silk Lines and Paper Hulls
- Singlebarbed
- Sipping Emergers
- Southern Tier Fly Fisher
- Strid Art
- Sweaty Waders
- The Agitated Angler
- The Caddis Fly
- The Female Angle
- The Fin
- The Outdooress
- The Ripple
- The Watery Rave
- Third Coast Fly
- This River Is Wild
- Trout Underground
- Trout Waders
- True North Trout
- TV Angler
- Up North Maine Fly Castings
- Urban Fly
- Urban Fly Fisher
- Urbn Outdoors
- Way Upstream
- Western Fly Fishing
- Will Fish For Work
- Yukon Goes Fishing
General Fishing
General Outdoors
Save the World
- Blogfish
- Blue Ocean Institute
- Bonefish and Tarpon Trust
- Casting for Recovery
- Coastal Voices
- Ethical Fisherman
- Everglades Foundation
- Friends of the Connetquot
- Mine Watch
- Project Healing Waters
- Save the Bay
- Save the Bluefin
- Save The River
- Save the Sound
- Sound Health
- Stop Pebble Mine
- Stripers Forever
- Theodore Roosevelt Conservation Project
- TIBS
- Tribal Bonefish
- Yale e360
Archives
Meta
I’m glad that discussion has been resolved.lol
Yeah that’s one more 20th century problem we don’t have to worry about.
Mr. Southard is probably still turning in his wet flybox to this day………
He’s probably enraged from beyond about the Moffitt Angling System.
Well, now that’s different. Not. Sounds like the lure/bait pissing contests I have with my freinds. At any rate, it would be nice to find a copy of that book. Check out how much this guy is selling a first edition for: http://www.ricksrods.com/rrimages/vintage%20tackle/books%20and%20paper%20goods/books__paper_goods.htm